How to Make Compost

Building a Compost Pile That Doesn't Smell

Learning how to make compost properly is actually really fun (IMHO). By knowing a few secrets, you can make compost fairly quickly and without smell. Compost will become one of your most prized "crops", especially when you see the resulting benefits of compost in your vibrant, healthy plants and higher yields. The video walks you through the whole process, and below that is the text version, which covers more detail and has links to other related articles.

Why Compost?

A beautiful and productive vegetable garden is only half of an equation - the half that pulls nutrients and minerals out of the soil for us to eat as vegetables.

Composting is the other half of the equation, the half that puts organic matter and some nutrients back into the soil*. The more diverse the ingredients that you put in the compost, the more nutrients you will be providing to your plants. 

*New information: as our agricultural soils have become depleted of minerals over the years, so has our food. Most compost ingredients, including manure, no longer have sufficient minerals to supply vegetables with nutrition. It is very important now to do a soil test, and amend your garden with the appropriate organic fertilizers.

Since compost supplies the organic matter that feeds beneficial microbes and that binds cation nutrients in the soil, it is still important for every vegetable gardener to learn how to make compost. Homemade compost is way better that 99% of commercial composts, which are usually made of waste ingredients like wood chips (= no nutrients), feedlot manure (= antibiotics and growth hormones), and even sewage sludge (= peed-out pharmaceuticals and hormones).

What Can I Put in the Compost?

Compost is decayed organic matter, which can include leaves, grass clippings, kitchen vegetable scraps, egg shells, coffee grounds, fall garden refuse and manure (in moderate quantities). Avoid using meat scraps, pet poop or woody twigs because they can (respectively) attract critters, contain pathogens, and be slow to break down.

How to Build the Compost Pile

Before building a compost pile, you may want to read the compost bins review article to help you decide what type of compost bin to buy or build, if you don't have one already.

Compost bins help speed decomposition, keep critters out, and can actually be an attractive addition to the garden. There are many good ones on the market, but the best one I've ever used I built myself for about $40. out of fencing cedar from Home Depot. The unique design of this homemade compost bin makes it especially easy to work and turn the compost when necessary, plus it is the most beautiful compost bin I've ever seen.

Whichever bin you use, read through the following before building your pile so you understand the basics of how to make compost properly. A compost pile that will be odor-free needs a balance of the following:

  • "Green" stuff - those materials that are higher in nitrogen, such as fresh grass clippings, vegetable scraps, weeds (preferably without seeds), coffee grounds, etc. These materials aren't necessarily green in color, but they are usually heavier and wetter than "browns".
  • "Brown" stuff - materials higher in carbon, such as dried leaves, straw, fall crop wastes, etc. These materials are often brown or straw colored, and are usually light and dry.
  • Water
  • Air

What constitutes a balance? By volume, you should have about 2-3 times more brown (high carbon) stuff than green (high nitrogen) stuff. The pile should be kept about as moist as a wrung-out sponge. Every once in awhile the pile should be fluffed and mixed up using a garden or hay fork to make sure the lower levels get enough air.

Build the pile in layers - about an inch of vegetable scraps, fresh grass clippings or weeds, then about 3 inches of dried leaves or straw. It's a good idea to have both a compost bin and a wire-sided leaf bin, so that when you get an inch or so of kitchen scraps built up in the compost pile, you have easy access to a couple of bucketfuls of dried leaves to cover them with.

Sign up for our
tip-filled, free ezine
Lorraine's Garden
and receive the
FREE 15-Page

E-mail Address
First Name (optional)

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Lorraine's Garden.

After you add the leaves, mix the layers together a little with a garden or hay fork, and sprinkle some water on it with the hose. Keep layering and mixing like this as the days go by until the compost bin is full, which might take anywhere from 4 weeks to 6 months to fill, depending on how much kitchen and yard waste you generate.

For fastest breakdown and to prevent odor, the pile should be fluffed and mixed every few weeks (or more, for fastest turnaround time). One reason I prefer the bin I built over the big black plastic storebought kind is that accessing the contents is very easy when it's time for mixing or even inverting the pile.

If the pile has the right balance of carbon and nitrogen along with the right balance of water and air, the microbes will go to town eating it up, and the pile will heat up. I have measured temperatures of 160° F at the center of a freshly-made compost pile! This is too hot, though - t's best to keep it below 150° by airing it out if it's getting too hot.

If you're still not sure if you want to start your own composting operation, you may like to read Top Ten Myths About Making Compost

Now that you've learned how to make compost, you can supercharge its benefit to the garden by using some of it to make actively aerated compost tea. After your compost is "finished", or done decomposing, it will be filled with beneficial microorganisms that help the garden in many ways, and are multiplied greatly in the tea.

Final Considerations

Learning how to make compost isn't rocket science. Don't be intimidated if this article if makes it sound hard! It's not. Compost will happen all by itself even if you do nothing to manage it. It just could take awhile, and might smell bad in the meantime. But even if you don't manage it optimally, the stuff will break down by itself naturally over time.

If the pile does start to smell or it's not breaking down, go to the when compost stinks article for compost troubleshooting tips.

One Bin or Two?
Whether you have one bin or two is not just a matter of volume - it will affect how you process and harvest compost. Two bins are recommended if you have more than a few square feet of garden. One bin will be the "open" bin that you keep adding stuff to, and the other will be the "closed" bin that you have already filled and is in the process of breaking down. If you don't stop adding stuff to a compost pile at some point, you're always going to have un-broken-down stuff in it.

Can't I Just Toss Kitchen Scraps Directly In the Garden?
If you're wondering why you shouldn't just put your vegetable scraps directly on the garden (a logical question), it's because the breakdown process itself will temporarily rob your soil of nutrients. As the hungry fungi and bacteria eat the kitchen scraps, they will temporarily pull the nutrients they need to build their bodies out of the soil, creating a deficiency. When those bacteria later die and their bodies decompose, the nutrients return to the soil. Better to do this process in a compost pile or bin.

Knowing how to make compost is an important skill for all vegetable gardeners, but it is especially important if you want to master the art of survival gardening.

I love to make compost. It closes the loop for me, letting me participate in the full cycle of life in the garden. Now that you know how to make compost without smell, I hope you find composting as fun and gratifying as I do!

And if you're looking for a compost pail for your kitchen counter, check out my compost pail buying guide.

You Are Here: Vegetable Gardening Home > How to Make Compost

Help share the skills and spread the joy
of organic vegetable gardening, and please...

Like us on Facebook!

Thank You!

New! Comments

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.

Share Your Favorite Compost Bin Design With Us!

Do you have a great compost bin design, or a favorite commercial bin? Share a photo with us, and tell us why you love it.

Protected by Copyscape Online Plagiarism Detection

You Are Here: Vegetable Gardening Home > How to Make Compost

You Can Help
Support This Site
by Shopping At:

Only the Best for your Yard & Garden -

Compost System

is only 12"x18" and is perfect for those with balcony or container gardens 

icon icon

Jora Dual Batch
Compost Tumbler
For making serious quantities of compost year-round, quickly

Pyramid Composter
One of the best of the "top-to-bottom" style plastic bin composters. Large capacity.

icon icon

Dual Batch
Compost Tumbler

is the BEST of the spinners because you can finish one batch while adding new scraps to the other

Worm Factory®
Red worms are master composters! Odor free, small-batch composting in your kitchen or basement. REALLY fun for kids (and grownups...) 

Brushed Stainless
Compost Pail

The most durable and attractive pail there is, with odor filters in the lid.


Scrap Happy
Hangs on drawer for easy collecting, then pop in freezer until full. Out of sight, and no smell ever.

icon icon